News
A sad tale of positive cash flow property
Friday 30th of April 2010
There is a view that property investing is easy and making money is a given. Well a story today shows how it can all go terribly wrong.
Last year we profiled in the NZ Property Investor Magazine a young man who was doing some amazing things. The guy, Laurence Pope (22), basically bought a street load of houses in the Waikato town of Paeroa as an investment.
He became pretty popular with the locals as he transformed what was referred to by some as a “ghetto” into a much smarter street.
Meanwhile other property investors where pretty impressed with his deeds.
However, things have gone wrong. His parents who acted as guarantors are reportedly in some difficulty and the bank probably hasn’t done too well either.
Bayleys have sold eight of the properties in mortgagee sales to other investors across the region.
The homes sold under the hammer for between $64,000 and $90,000, yet Pope had paid around $120,000 for each of the properties and improved many of them.
It’s sad to see someone who made a difference in a town like this fail, but it also shows some of the risks involved in residential property investing.
On the upside the sale also demonstrates what we talk about in the May issue of NZ Property Investor magazine – that is the return to positive cash flow investing.
The article has a comprehensive table showing readers areas throughout the country where you can find cash flow positive properties. Not surprisingly many of them are in the provincial regions.
According to Bayleys Pope’s Paeroa properties sold on rental yields of seven to 10%. These are well above comparable investments in the likes of Auckland, Wellington or Christchurch, and show that by looking outside the square, there are plenty of excellent investment opportunities available in the residential sector.
Last year we profiled in the NZ Property Investor Magazine a young man who was doing some amazing things. The guy, Laurence Pope (22), basically bought a street load of houses in the Waikato town of Paeroa as an investment.
He became pretty popular with the locals as he transformed what was referred to by some as a “ghetto” into a much smarter street.
Meanwhile other property investors where pretty impressed with his deeds.
However, things have gone wrong. His parents who acted as guarantors are reportedly in some difficulty and the bank probably hasn’t done too well either.
Bayleys have sold eight of the properties in mortgagee sales to other investors across the region.
The homes sold under the hammer for between $64,000 and $90,000, yet Pope had paid around $120,000 for each of the properties and improved many of them.
It’s sad to see someone who made a difference in a town like this fail, but it also shows some of the risks involved in residential property investing.
On the upside the sale also demonstrates what we talk about in the May issue of NZ Property Investor magazine – that is the return to positive cash flow investing.
The article has a comprehensive table showing readers areas throughout the country where you can find cash flow positive properties. Not surprisingly many of them are in the provincial regions.
According to Bayleys Pope’s Paeroa properties sold on rental yields of seven to 10%. These are well above comparable investments in the likes of Auckland, Wellington or Christchurch, and show that by looking outside the square, there are plenty of excellent investment opportunities available in the residential sector.
Comments (8)
Jeff Johnson
I remember reading this article and wondering how he could possibly afford this? Most investors I know hold between 1 and 4 properties and make sure there is sufficient equity to ride a downturn or an increase in interest rates. Positive cashflow is the only way I know (unless you have strong cash reserves) to have a successful long term property portfolio. Speculation is for the already well off, who would not have made this msitake anyway. I am also alarmed (as I was at the time) that NZPI did not offer a caution with this story, which seemed too good to be true even then - and it was.
0
0
14 years ago
Kate Savage
It doesn't matter whether you are young or old, people make mistakes- emotion takes over from commonsense. If I had the knowledge earlier that I have now, I would have practically paid each house off before I bought another.
0
0
14 years ago
John Crawford
I hope NZPI puts this story on the cover of there next issue, as they did with the "Angel of Harlem" cover originally on him. Maybe that way a few of these young investors might learn that property is not a straight line to riches, take a step back and learn to crawl before running.
0
0
14 years ago
Robbie Mitchell
In Response To...
<br />Heidi Says:
<br />May 3rd, 2010 at 9:43 am
<br />MrB Says:
<br />April 30th, 2010 at 6:33 pm
<br />Just goes to show: You can’t put an old head on young shoulders
<br />
<br />Well he did have old heads…his parents the guarantors!!! Lesson don’t overcommit to your off spring!!!!
<br />
<br />I agree we need to teach them to make their own way...not pay their way!
0
0
14 years ago
Bernie Blakely
Just goes to show: You can't put an old head on young shoulders.
0
0
14 years ago
Richard Jacobs
I agree with Nancy, give me a lower yield in a bigger city, with a more stable population and employment outlook and where there is greater certainty of rental growth.<br /><br />Problem with too many investors they don't do their home work, anyone can make money in a boom, but it's having some understanding on how to ride out the bust. Too many of the property advisers out there are not telling the who truth about managing cycles. Pope was always going to be too highly geared. Greed, often overrides commonsense.
0
0
14 years ago
Jan Berry
Why does the end of your article say there are good returns to be made in provincial centres when obviously this young guy started by making good returns in a small town but when the value of his properties dropped he got into financial difficulties. To make real wealth through property you have to buy in areas with a high population and good infrastructure and invest for long term capital growth.
0
0
14 years ago
Heidi Wehrle
MrB Says:
<br />April 30th, 2010 at 6:33 pm
<br />Just goes to show: You can’t put an old head on young shoulders
<br />
<br />Well he did have old heads...his parents the guarantors!!! Lesson don't overcommit to your off spring!!!!
0
0
14 years ago
5 min read