Blogs
Join Up, Join Up: The latest adviser regulation twist
Thursday 10th of July 2008
I’ve commented before about the tortuous process adviser regulation has gone through and now it appears to have gotten to the mad stage.Discussion on how the sector should be regulated has gone on for years. There have been task forces, discussion papers, U-turns – the lot.
The road has been as windy as crossing the Southern Alps, rather than being straight, sharp and direct.
It appears the government is pretty hell-bent on getting this through Parliament before the election. While there was some thought this would be a piece of legislation which lingers, the fact that the select committee hearing it sat on a Monday (very unusual) and reports officials are advancing plans behind the scene, a pre-election passing looks highly probable.
That’s fine, but as we report today it appears there is a whole new model being promoted which hasn’t had much discussion in the industry, particularly by the people who will be regulated – advisers.
Under this accredited institution model advisers would have to belong to a product provider who would be responsible for regulating advisers who sell its wares.
I’m struggling to see the benefits for consumers with this model.
It seems that institutions are making a land grab for distribution; that they could shield poor quality advisers from scrutiny; and that they risk brand damage if an adviser goes off the rails.
I met someone yesterday who told a story about an adviser putting all of a couple’s retirement savings (around $150,000) into one finance company. Under this regulatory model that company could be the accredited institution, and one would question (especially if it was someone like Bridgecorp) what sort of investor protection there would be.
This new development, is major for advisers. I would like to hear your views on it, how much if anything you know about it, whether there has been any consultation and what you think the regulatory model should look like.
Use the comments box below to leave your thoughts or email them to thoughts@goodreturns.co.nz
Comments (3)
Hamish Patel
ummmm whats the point of this bill apart from trying to eradicate independent advisors?
0
0
16 years ago
Nigel Tate
I find it interesting that Vance the chair of the ISI is stating that this is the view of it's members and yet one of it's members (assuming Tower still is) is coming out saying something totally different.
I would not at all be keen to see Accredited Institutions able to control the advisers out there, even as the suggestion is that they (the controlled advisers) could only sell product from that institution.
Congratulations to Sam for his stance, it is high time we advisers/planners were released from the institutional shackles to do what is best for the client without restriction as long as we do place the "Client First".
We will need to take responsibility for the advice we give and as long as we work within our area/s of competence this should not be an issue, however demonstrating our competencies will create the need for measures and wait for it, possibly better and ongoing training. Bring it on!!
0
0
16 years ago
Austin Fisher
(the future)
Mum or Dad investor - "I have lost my life savings because Cowboy Finance - who you recommended to me - has fallen over. What do you have to say?"
Adviser - " Well, blimey, it was an Accredited Institution so I thought it was OK. You must be gutted. Sorry! "
"Hello Government, you gave them Accredited Institution status. What do you have to say?"
Govt - "You'll never guess what they did - they told us they were solvent and it turns out they weren't! So we closed them down. That'll teach them. Your money? Oh...er...The Liquidators might be able to give you an answer. "
"Hello Liquidators. What do you have to say?"
Cowboy Finance liquidators - "We might be able to pay you back 20c in the $ in about 10 years time, you never know. But no promises! You might have to take a class action of some sort against the former directors of Cowboy Finance to get the rest of your money"
"Hello former Director of Cowboy Finance. What do you have to say?"
Former Director of Cowboy Finance - "sorry, can't hear you - the reception here in St Tropez is shocking. Bzzzzt kSSCCCHHH!"
0
0
16 years ago
2 min read