| Log In Subscribe for $0.99/week
Philip Macalister
Philip Macalister
2
2 Comment
Save Story
News

Go Mr Common Sense

Sunday 16th of March 2008
One thing which has intrigued me in recent months is how government MP Clayton Cosgrove is so anti real estate agents.

He seems to take whatever opportunity he can, even when he is overseas, to get stuck into real estate agents, labeling them all "land sharks" and implying they are just rip-off merchants.

Sure there are some dodgy ones, some questionable practices and some issues around the way agents are policed, but....are they all dodgy?

Clayton's language makes great sound bites for telly and radio, but isn't warranted.
Last week, after select committee hearings on the new real estate agent legislation, he was up to his same old tricks. However, United Future leader, Peter Dunne, (who calls himself Mr Common Sense) played a card not many expected.

In a release which has probably gone unreported, he says the United Future party "will withdraw its support for the Real Estate Agents Bill...unless there are major changes to the legislation and the sponsoring minister, Clayton Cosgrove, adopts a more consultative attitude."

"It was clear from today's Morning Report interview that Mr Cosgrove is maintaining a belligerent, bully boy attitude towards the Real Estate Institute, and his claims to be consulting with the Institute are undermined by his inability even to get the name of the Institute's President right," he said.

There is no doubt that the real estate industry needs better processes to clear out the sharks and the dodgy operators, but that won't be achieved by bellowing at everyone and listening to no-one.
Comments (2)
Greg Clinch
I couldn't agree more with Lee Kammerer in his message posted above.<br />I was also at the N.Z.F.I.F. conference in Chch last October and heard this dickhead too.<br />To start with, it is very difficult to take someone with that ludicrous 'hair-style' seriously... then he opens his trap and leaves us in no doubt that he is desperate to make his mark, however deperately.<br />I am an investor ( commercial property), developer (res and comm.) and also hold a real estate sales certificate so I have had plenty of exposure to real estate people - the vast majority are bloody good sorts and I'd rather spend my time with them than fuckwits like Cosgrove.
0 0
16 years ago
Lee Kammerer
100% correct. The guy (Cosgrove) is a complete idiot. His speech to the New Zealand Property Investors' Conference in Christchurch last year was the worst I have ever heard from a politician of any shade. Go Kate Wilkinson in Waimakariri!!!
0 0
16 years ago
Comments to GoodReturns.co.nz go through an approval process. Comments which are defamatory, abusive or in some way deemed inappropriate will not be approved.
Next Article
[OPINION] Recessionary times
[OPINION] Recessionary times
5 min read
[OPINION] How to make 20% from commercial property
[OPINION] How to make 20% from commercial property
10 min read
Latest News
The run of play is towards more and more underwriting, and not just at the traditional new business stage
The run of play is towards more and more underwriting, and not just at the traditional new business stage
3 min read
Value of index tracking seen in the numbers, says Kernel
Value of index tracking seen in the numbers, says Kernel
3 min read
NZ sharemarket starts week up 0.6%
NZ sharemarket starts week up 0.6%
4 min read
Can Games Teach Financial Literacy?
Can Games Teach Financial Literacy?
4 min read
Latest Comments
New customers locked out of ASB’s pre-approvals
As much as I disapprove of the ASB stance, I totally understand it, ESPECIALLY as the ComCom expect us to put an application to 4-5 banks, and not just the one we believe to suit the client the best. By demanding this, we would be tying the banks up with 4-5 times the applications necessary to secure a settlement. Banks would know that only 20-25% of applications are going to make it through to settlement. This shotgun approach is why banks are overloaded.
2 months ago Andy Phillipson
New customers locked out of ASB’s pre-approvals
This is pure BS from the major banks. In front of ComCom earlier in the year they denied any policy of channel inequality yet there clearly is from some (at board level) both in turnaround times and cashbacks for example. They need to staff up, sort their antiquated IT and give Advisers the respect they deserve. New Zealand borrowers are voting with their feet and using Advisers more and more. Are some banks starting their pushback? One as done it before so no surprise there.
2 months ago Jeff Royle
New customers locked out of ASB’s pre-approvals
As a financial adviser, business owner and ex-banker/home lender in NZ & Australia with almost 20 years experience I can tell you that this is very concerning for several reasons - first one being that as bank staff you still get paid regardless of whether you put the approval thru, lazy/incompetent/time poor bankers are often declining loans rather than taking the time to push a difficult deal thru as they get paid either way, as a financial adviser who doesn't get paid unless the deal settles we are more committed to securing an approval which is why more volume now comes thru the broker channels. This feels like it's the banks way of reducing costs by not having to pay brokerage to advisers when bank lenders doing nothing should be sitting on the broker overflow lines. This directly affects small businesses and is another example of banks playing God & redirecting profit margins back to their own coffers - there is no valid excuse for branch lenders doing nothing to not be sitting on these overflow lines. It makes a mockery of giving the choice back to the clients who are already typically having poor banking experiences when dealing direct with bank staff.l and in no way supports small businesses already doing it tough.
2 months ago Natasha Viliamu
New customers locked out of ASB’s pre-approvals
Another major bank today has announced no pre approvals via Advisers for under 80% LVR. That's at least 3 of them. All applications whether direct or through Advisers should be given the same priority and go through the same assessment process. Banks don't appear to have invested (enough) in staff or technology and given how much money they make, it is unacceptable. Lets hope it gets sorted soon!
2 months ago Craig Pope
New customers locked out of ASB’s pre-approvals
Sorry I don’t believe ASB are overrun with applications as we are traditional in a slow market so I think this” high volume “ excuse is rubbish, ASB will still post a massive profit due margins being so high but they can’t hire extra staff?? This is a disgrace! for consumers that choose to go through an independent mortgage adviser ASB are turning them away, but an ASB branch can write that deal no problem? , what happened to offering choice to the consumer? And being competitive? Are Comcom silent on this? Are the dealer groups /master FAP’s who have a monopoly over mortgage advisers’ access to bank mortgage lending silent on this? Why do we pay dealer groups /Master FAPs thousands in fees and costs if they can’t or don’t want to even back the people that pay their wages. All mortgage advisers want is an even playing field no more no less. How would ASB feel if all mortgage advisers in NZ stopped sending business to them for a few months?
2 months ago Valkyrie Vulcan