CoreLogic’s latest Pain and Gain report shows that the number of resales resulting in a gross loss in the third quarter of 2017 rose to 4.3%. 

Nationwide, total gains declined by nearly $900 million.

In Auckland, total profits from gain-making property resales came in at $1.56 billion, which was half of the peak value of $3.0 billion in the third quarter of 2015.

CoreLogic head of research Nick Goodall says that capital gains have slowed and, in some cases, moved into negative territory. 

“This may be a sign of market fatigue with buyers choosing to cash out of the market rather than risk holding the property and potentially experiencing further loss.”

Apartments are faring worse than houses in the resale stakes, with 10.1% of apartments being sold at a loss as compared to 4.0% of houses.

That equates to a median loss of $25,000 for apartments as compared to $18,000 for houses.

Both Auckland and Christchurch are seeing an upwards trend for resales at a loss for both investors and owner occupiers.

But it is investors who are faring worse, with 4.1% in Auckland and 15.2% in Christchurch experiencing loss making resales.

Goodall says the lift in the investor proportion bucks the trend of the last few years.

“Investors are under increased scrutiny from the new government with the quality of rental properties needing to improve and to be managed by future regulation by the recently passed Healthy Homes Guarantee Act.

“This may cause more investors to sell out of the market to avoid bearing the costs of improvement or to raise funds for other rental properties.”

Looking at markets around the country, Christchurch saw the highest proportion of loss-making resales: up to 11.1% from 8.1% in the previous quarter.

It was followed by Tauranga (3.9%) and Auckland (3.3%), which equated to a slight increase for both as compared to the previous quarter.

Hamilton and Wellington’s share of loss-making sales remains flat, at around 1.5%.

The story was very different for Queenstown which, for the second quarter in a row, had no resales at a loss.

Goodall says this reflects the strength of the market there.

However, nationally resale gains ($3.4 billion) continued to dominate resale losses ($30 million) over the third quarter.