News

Advisers not sold on SOE miracle

Thursday 3rd of May 2012

The government has launched a website that provides information on the government's share offers through the IPOs of state-owned power companies Mighty River Power, Genesis and Meridian and coal miner Solid Energy, as well as a reduction in the government's stake in Air New Zealand

While the issue is a hot one politically, financial markets are hoping the "mixed ownership model", which is expected to raise between $7-9 billion for the government, will give New Zealand's share market at least a temporary boost.

However, Good Returns has spoken to a number of financial advisers who have questioned how much long-term benefit New Zealand's stock exchange will get from the listings.

"Despite the inflows fund managers are getting from KiwiSaver, turnover in the New Zealand stock market is derisorily low," said one adviser, who compared the IPOs to previous listings of energy companies on the NZX.

"Did the listings of Contact and Vector set the New Zealand stock market alight in the long term?  Aren't Mighty River Power, Genesis and Meridian just like Contact?

"However, I've got no doubt investment bankers and stock brokers are rubbing their hands together and there are lots of individuals that think they are going to make a quick killing by buying into these things and then selling them to institutions for a profit."

Another adviser said the SOE floats were a welcome development and good for mum and dad investors, but would do little to add to the scale of the New Zealand market.

"The guts of it is we're small - if you look at each of the SOEs one of those big super funds could buy the whole thing."

Comments (2)
Mike King
"What really worries me is that there is little comment on the potential investor seeking financial advice before participating. Lack of professional advice can often lead to the greed factor taking over particularly if the media suggests that there is a quick dollar to be made." Surely, the overarching principle of Caveat Emptor should still count for SOMETHING. If some people CHOOSE to proceed without the awesome wisdom of an AFA, they are entitled to do so.
0 0
12 years ago

Ray Storey
Or sought, even.
0 0
12 years ago

Comments to GoodReturns.co.nz go through an approval process. Comments which are defamatory, abusive or in some way deemed inappropriate will not be approved.