The Taxation (Annual Rates, Foreign Superannuation, and Remedial Matters) Bill was recently amended so people who have applied to transfer their pensions before April 1 are eligible for the 15% amnesty tax rate. 

Tom Gilbert, of Pension Transfers, said in many cases people would be foolish not to do it, if their intention was to live and retire in New Zealand.  He had done some calculations in which people were $60,000 better off in tax terms with the 15% amnesty.

But Dai Eveleigh, head of investments and UK pensions at advisory firm First Capital Financial Services, said not everyone would benefit from the amnesty.

He said some investors were getting incorrect advice that could leave them worse off, often from financial advisers and accountants who were not specialists in the area.

“British expats are rushing to beat the deadline… however the inaccurate and false information in the marketplace is alarming and could end in many expats making poor or wrong decisions.

“I’ve even heard of people being told they have to transfer into KiwiSaver. The problem with that is that if a client transfers funds into KiwiSaver from a UK pension, then returns to live in the UK and makes a withdrawal from their KiwiSaver fund, they will trigger an unauthorised withdrawal penalty of 55%.”

Others had been told to take the amnesty when they would be better off using the existing tax rules, because their rate would be lower than 15%.

Tax consultant Terry Baucher agreed that investors needed to seek advice on whether moving their superannuation was the right thing for them. “They need to think about the whole investment consideration involved and take it from there. It’s not always just about tax.”

The IRD said it did not keep data on how many people might be eligible for the 15% amnesty.