News

Regulation makes MRP discussion difficult: Leitch

Tuesday 9th of April 2013

The offer document for the shares, which are expected to start trading next month, was made public on Friday.

Shares are likely to be priced between $2.35 and $2.80 and there have been suggestions that uncertainty over Rio Tinto’s plans for Tiwai Point may push the price to the lower end of that scale.

But investors will nominate a dollar amount they wish to purchase, not a number of shares, so if there are a lot of would-be purchasers, the share price may be pushed up.

PAA chairman Peter Leitch said most potential purchasers would have to get their information from the media, because advisers were hamstrung by regulation. “Advisers can’t really comment. People have got to read the prospectus and make their own decisions.”

He said that whereas in the past, a client might ring an adviser and ask for an opinion, now regulation required that advisers go through the full advice process in order to make any comment. “I can’t tell them whether they are right to buy shares. I would need to say ‘we need to have a meeting’. It’s better just to say I don’t do that.”

Leitch said it was safer for media commentators to give their opinions than it was for financial advisers to weigh in. “It’s the first share float where a lot of people have expressed interest and they will want reassurance, they will call people like me and I kind of can’t say anything.”

Comments (6)
Alison Gilbert
I agree with Peter's comments. Furthermore, for a reason I don't understand, brokers are not allowed to publish their research on new offerings until something like 40 days *after* the listing date. By which time. of course, it is not so useful. However, it seems Morningstar can release its research before listing date (useful for those AFAs who won't cross the road unless Morningstar holds their hand). But after Morningstar's DO NOT SUBSCRIBE recommendation on Fonterra (surely one of the worst calls of the year), I would take anything they say with a grain of salt.......
0 0
11 years ago

Broker Broker
Maybe investors could hold the Government liable for lack of any personalised advice or need analysis if the shares drop in value? After all, they made the rules? They have just decided not to follow them themselves...sets a great example ah?
0 0
11 years ago

Murray Weatherston
Ally can you elaborate on what you understand the basis of the 40 day rule. I could perhaps understand it if this related only to brokers actually involved in putting the offer together (e.g. lead broker) But I assume those brokers not putting out research will be happy to take the brokerage on any applications bearing their stamp.
0 0
11 years ago

Steven Barton
Obviously there will not be any quality broking house research on Mighty River prior to listing. They all have a massive conflict of interest and obviously want to sell as much product as possible. They also do not want to upset the powers that be, as there are supposed to be a few more large floats over the next 18 months. Talking of conflicts of interest, it seems amazing that when a potential investor showed an expression of interest and they did not state a particular broker name, within 48 hours a broker had contacted them. They had no history with the broking firm, nor did they hold any direct shares or bonds in their own name. Obviously there must be an information leak somewhere. One of the most interesting areas of the offer document is the financial information. Should advisers and potential investors really believe the projections? If the projections prove to be reasonably accurate, there is a massive increase in profitability. It almost looks like the government would not lose any cash-flow as the increase in dividends looks set to make up for the sale of 49%. People need to remember that the projection is only one potential outcome, based on a myriad of assumptions.
0 0
11 years ago

alan milton
Boutique: a small shop or department selling clothes and other items of fashion.(OED)
0 0
11 years ago

Brent Sheather
Well said AFA maggins ! show us the money Morningstar ! How many analysts do you have dedicated to NZ equities and what is their experience..
0 0
11 years ago

Comments to GoodReturns.co.nz go through an approval process. Comments which are defamatory, abusive or in some way deemed inappropriate will not be approved.